IR vs RF | difference between IR remote and RF remote controls
This page compares IR (infrared) remote and RF (Radio Frequency) remote control and mentions difference between IR remote and RF remote controls.
RF stands for Radio Frequency waves which range from 3 KHz to 300 GHz in the frequency scale. IR stands for Infrared waves which range from 300 GHz to 400 THz in the scale. Wavelength of infrared ranges from 700 nm to 1 mm. Typically, the remote control device operates on IR (Infrared) or RF frequency range. Both remotes are used for the same applications to control the remote device mostly television (TV). Let us understand difference between IR and RF remote controls.
Due to advantages of RF over IR as well as easy replacement of IR LEDs with RF Transmitter and IR receiver with RF receiver many IR remote controls are now replaced by RF remote controls. But RF hardware is consired complex compare to IR hardware. Hence choice between IR remote or RF remote lies with the applications of use.
|Specifications||IR (Infrared) Remote||RF (Radio Frequency) Remote|
|Coverage Range||upto 10 meters||upto 50 meters at LOS|
|Data rate||500 bps to 1 kbps||upto 100 kbps|
|Regional Regulation||No limitation||It has regulation limits as defined in ETSI/FCC. There is need of compliance tests to be conducted.|
|Power consumption of transmit part during power ON state||20 to 150 mA, this depends on LEDs and coverage range||5 to 20 mA|
|Power consumption of receive part during STAND-BY state||Approx. 1 mA||Approx. 5 mA in continuous receiving mode|
|Bidirectional mode of operation||Not possible due to power consumption||Possible|
|Number of bits per frame||maximum 40 bits||about 80 to 140 bits per frame|
|Protocols||IR uses modulation techniques such as pulse distance coding and manchester coding to represent 1s and 0s on 38 KHz carrier.||RF uses any modulation techniques such as ASK and FSK to represent 1s and 0s.|
|EXAMPLE||MSP430 based TV IR remote control transmitter from TI||PMAfob is RF Remote transmitter from Infineon|
What is Difference between
RFID advantages disadvantages IrDA advantages disadvantages NFC vs RFID Bluetooth vs WiFi vs NFC vs RFID INSTEON vs Zigbee INSTEON vs X10 INSTEON vs HomePlug INSTEON vs Z-wave zigbee vs Z-wave Bluetooth vs zigbee Bluetooth vs BLE