Active vs Passive Infrared Sensor : Difference between Active and Passive IR Sensor

Infrared (IR) sensors are widely used in various applications, including motion detection, proximity sensing, and environmental monitoring. These sensors can be categorized into active and passive IR sensors based on their working principles and components. Active IR sensors emit infrared radiation and detect reflections, while passive IR sensors detect infrared radiation emitted by surrounding objects. This page compares Active IR (Infrared) Sensor vs Passive IR (Infrared) Sensor and mentions difference between Active IR sensor and Passive IR sensor types including their respective advantages and disadvantages. This guide helps in selecting the right sensor for specific applications such as security systems, industrial automation, and household devices.

Active Infrared Sensor

Active infrared sensors consist of both an emitter (e.g., LED or laser diode) and a receiver (e.g., photodiode or phototransistor). The emitter transmits infrared light, which is reflected off an object and detected by the receiver. The presence or movement of an object changes the amount of reflected light, allowing the sensor to detect proximity, distance, or motion.

The key features of active infrared (IR) sensor are as follows.
➨Self-Illumination: Active IR sensors emit their own infrared light, making them independent of external light sources.
➨Detection Mechanism: Measures the reflection or interruption of the emitted IR light by an object.
➨Range: Short to medium range, depending on the power of the emitter and sensitivity of the receiver.

Applications: Used for object detection, proximity sensing, motion detection, and industrial automation. They are commonly used in burglar alarms, automatic door openers, and vehicle reversing systems.

Advantages of active IR sensor

1. Can work in both light and dark environments.
2. More reliable detection in low-light conditions compared to passive sensors.
3. Can measure distance to an object based on reflection intensity.

Disadvantages of active IR sensor

1. May be affected by environmental factors like dust, smoke, and fog.
2. Limited range compared to other sensing technologies.

Passive Infrared Sensor

Passive infrared sensors do not emit any infrared light. Instead, they detect infrared radiation naturally emitted by objects in their field of view, particularly warm-blooded animals and humans. PIR sensors work by detecting changes in infrared radiation levels caused by motion or temperature variations.

The key features of passive infrared (IR) sensor are as follows.
➨No Emission: Do not emit any radiation; only detect infrared radiation from objects.
➨Detection Mechanism: Measures changes in the infrared radiation in its surroundings.
➨Range: Short to medium range, typically up to 10-20 meters for human detection.

Applications: Widely used for motion detection in security systems, automatic lighting, and HVAC systems.

Advantages of passive IR sensor

1. Low power consumption.
2. Reliable motion detection without needing an external light source.
3. Less sensitive to environmental conditions like fog and dust.

Disadvantages of passive IR sensor

1. Cannot detect stationary objects.
2. Sensitivity can be affected by ambient temperature changes.

Difference between active and passive IR sensor

Following table mentions similarities and difference between Active and passive IR sensors.

Parameter Active Infrared Sensor Passive Infrared Sensor
Working Principle Emits IR light and detects reflection or interruption. Detects infrared radiation emitted by objects.
Components Includes both emitter and receiver. Contains only a detector (no emitter).
Emission Emits its own infrared light. Does not emit any light.
Detection Range Short to medium range, based on reflected light intensity. Short range, typically 10-20 meters for human detection.
Object Detection Detects objects whether stationary or moving. Detects only moving objects or changes in radiation.
Environmental Sensitivity More sensitive to smoke, dust, and fog. Less sensitive to environmental factors.
Power Consumption Higher power consumption due to the emitter. Lower power consumption due to passive detection.
Cost and Complexity Higher cost and complexity due to additional components. Lower cost and simpler design.
Applications Proximity sensing, object detection, automation. Motion detection, security systems, automatic lighting.

Conclusion

Active and passive IR sensors are designed to cater to different sensing requirements. Active IR sensors, with their ability to emit and detect reflected infrared light, are suitable for detecting proximity and motion in various lighting conditions. Passive IR sensors, which detect changes in infrared radiation from the environment, are ideal for detecting the presence and movement of warm objects. Choosing between active and passive IR sensors depends on factors like power consumption, detection range, and environmental conditions.

Different types of Sensors Related links

Advantages and Disadvantages of other Sensor Types

Capacitive    Inductive    Photoelectric    Ultrasonic    Infrared    Motion    Biometric    Force    Humidity    Temperature    Light    Barometer    Sound    pH    Soil Moisture   

What is Difference between

RF and Wireless Terminologies