Difference Ferrite diode,P-I-N diode-Ferrite and P-I-N diode

This page compares ferrite diode vs P-I-N diode and describes difference between ferrite diode and P-I-N diode.Advantages and disadvantages of ferrite and semiconductor control devices are also mentioned.

As we know switches, attenuators and phase shifters are the control devices which are used to provide control of amplitude/phase of RF signal in the microwave circuits.

These control devices are constructed with the use of ferrite devices or solid state devices. P-I-N diodes and FETs are most common solid state devices.

Advantages and Disadvantages of Ferrite control devices

Advantages: These devices are heavy in weight, slow in operation and expensive.
Disadvantages:They have high power handling and low loss.

The advantages of solid state control devices are smaller in size, fast in switching and are inexpensive. Due to these features they are widely used for various applications.

Difference between Ferrite diode and P-I-N diode

Following table mentions major difference between control devices such as ferrite diode and P-I-N diode.

Specifications Ferrite Diode P-I-N Diode
Speed of operation Slow, in msec range Fast, in µsec range
Loss Lower, About 0.2 dB Higher, About 0.5 dB
Cost Higher Lower
Weight More Less
Driver construction Complicated Simple
Size of device Large Small
Power Handling High Low

Diode and Transistor Related Links

GUNN Diode➤   Varactor Diode➤   Tunnel Diode➤   PIN Diode➤   Impatt Diode vs Trapatt Diode vs Baritt Diode➤   Tunnel vs normal P-N➤   Schottky Diode➤   Zener Diode➤   N-Channel FET vs P-Channel FET➤   Depletion Vs Enhancement MOSFET➤  

what is difference between

difference between FDM and OFDM
Difference between SC-FDMA and OFDM
Difference between SISO and MIMO
Difference between TDD and FDD
Difference between 802.11 standards viz.11-a,11-b,11-g and 11-n
Bluetooth vs zigbee
Fixed wimax vs mobile

RF and Wireless Terminologies