Difference between Direct ToF sensor and Indirect ToF sensor

This page compares DToF sensor Vs IToF sensor and mentions difference between Direct ToF sensor and Indirect ToF (Time of Flight) sensor.

Introduction : There are three major 3D sensing systems viz. structured light, stereo vision and time of flight. We will discuss distance estimation using Time of Flight (ToF) methods viz. Direct and Indirect ToF.

The Time of Flight technique works by illuminating scene with modulated light source and detecting reflected light. The light source can be continuous wave (CW) or pulsed.

Direct ToF Sensor | DToF Sensor

It sends out short light pulses and measures time until echo is received using SPAD (single-photon avalanche diode) detector. It uses vertical cavity surface emitting laser (VCSEL) with output pulse length of about 0.2 nsec to 5 nsec. This method is very accurate with multiple objects and immune to smudges on cover glass.

Direct ToF Sensor

The figure-1 depicts direct Time of Flight (dToF) method. This technique is best suited for single / few points ranging such as range finder.

Indirect ToF Sensor | IToF Sensor

It illuminates scene with intensity modulated light. It measures the phase shift between trasmitted waveform and received waveform. This phase shift is proportional to the distance. VCSEL output is 20 to 100 MHz modulated sine wave as shown in the figure-2. It uses standard CMOS technology.

Indirect ToF sensor

The figure-2 depicts indirect Time of Flight (iToF) method. This technique is best suited for 3D imaging.

Difference between DToF sensor and IToF sensor

Following table mentions difference between Direct ToF sensor and Indirect ToF sensor.

Comparison parameters Direct ToF (dToF) Sensor Indirect ToF (iToF) Sensor
Principle It uses stop watch approach to determine time delay. It uses phase shift difference between transmitted signal and reflected signal to determine time delay.
Time/Frequency of emitted signal It uses pulse with duration of 0.2 nsec to 5 nsec. It uses modulation frequencies in the range from 20 to 100 MHz.
Detector type used SPADs/APDs Detector : demodulation pixel (2 tap/4 tap), PMDs : 6 to 100 µm pixel size
Depth calculation method Histogram analysis In-pixel calculation
Pixel count sensors Smaller Medium to higher
Performance Fast acquision, no ambiguity Long integration time, ambiguity
Dynamic range Digital Analog
Use case Single/Few points ranging 3D imaging

➨Also refer LiDAR vs Time of Flight >> for difference between LiDAR and ToF.

Difference between Insteon and other technologies

IoT Wireless Technologies

WLAN    THREAD    EnOcean    LoRa    SIGFOX    WHDI    Zigbee   6LoWPAN   Zigbee RF4CE   Z-Wave   NFC   RFID   INSTEON  

Difference between MQTT and HTTP, REST, DDS, SMQTT and CoAP protocols

Advantages and Disadvantages of other Sensor Types

Capacitive    Inductive    Photoelectric    Ultrasonic    Infrared    Motion    Biometric    Force    Humidity    Temperature    Light    Barometer    Sound    pH    Soil Moisture   

Advantages and Disadvantages of other wireless technologies

IrDA    HomeRF    Bluetooth    Radar    RF    Wireless    Internet    Mobile Phone    IoT    Solar Energy    Fiber Optic    Satellite    GPS    RFID    AM and FM    LTE   

What is Difference between

RF and Wireless Terminologies