MOSFET vs IGBT | difference between MOSFET and IGBT
This page compares MOSFET vs IGBT and mentions difference between MOSFET and IGBT.
The full form of MOSFET is Metal Oxide Semiconductor Field Effect Transistor.
Figure-1 depicts 600 Volt SJ-MOSFET structure and circuit symbol.
Refer Depletion MOSFET vs Enhancement MOSFET➤ and MOSFET Fabrication Technology➤.
The full form of IGBT is Insulated Gate Bipolar Transistor. Figure-2 depicts 600 Volt G6H Trench IGBT structure and circuit symbol. Both the structures look same, but the main difference in IGBT p-substrate is added below the n-substrate.
There are two IGBT structures viz. NPT-IGBT (known as homogeneous structure) and PT-IGBT (known as epitaxial structure).
The PT (i.e. punch through) IGBT structure shows characteristic epitaxial layers with an N+-doped region
(i.e. buffer layer) and N--region on a p-doped substrate wafer.
The NPT (i.e. non punch through) IGBT structure is homogeneous N- -doped wafer. On backward side, a specially formed p-layer is created during wafer processing.
When one has to select between IGBT and MOSFET, IGBT is preferred for breakdown voltage greater than 1000Volt. MOSFET is preferred for breakdown voltages less than 250Volt.
Figure-3 mentions comparison of output characteristics between MOSFET and IGBT. Following table compares both MOSFET and IGBT. These factors will help one select the right device based on application and design need.
|Preferred device based on||MOSFET||IGBT|
|Based on conditions||High Switching Frequency (> 100kHz)||Low Switching Frequency (<20kHz)|
|Wide line and load conditions||High Power levels (above say 3 kW)|
|dv/dt on the diode is limited||High dv/dt needed to be handled by the diode|
|High light load efficiency is needed||High full load Efficiency is needed|
|Based on applications||Motor Drives (<250W)||Motor Drives (> 250W)|
|Universal input AC-DC flyback and forward converter power supplies||UPS and Welding H Bridge inverters|
|Low to Mid power PFCs (75W to 3 kW)||High power PFCs (> 3kW)|
|Solar Micro Inverters||High Power Solar/Wind Inverters (> 5kW)|
|Applications||• SMPS (Hard switching greater than 200 KHz),
• SMPS (ZVS less than 1000 watts),
• Battery charging
| • UPS(constant load, typically at low frequency),
• Welding(high average current, low frequency <50KHz, ZVS circuitry),
• Motor control(frequency <20KHz, short circuit/in-rush limit protection )
• Low power lighting(low frequency < 100 KHz)
MOSFET and BJT related links
PNP Transistor Vs NPN Transistor➤
BJT vs FET➤
JUGFET vs MOSFET➤
Depletion MOSFET vs Enhancement MOSFET➤
MOSFET Fabrication Technology➤
MOSFET vs BJT-Difference between MOSFET and BJT➤
Application Note-MOSFET as switch and amplifier➤
Difference between NMOS vs PMOS➤
What is Difference between
difference between FDM and OFDM
Difference between SC-FDMA and OFDM
Difference between SISO and MIMO
Difference between TDD and FDD
Difference between 802.11 standards viz.11-a,11-b,11-g and 11-n
OFDM vs OFDMA
CDMA vs GSM